What Happens at the Appeal Hearing

Who’s in the room

The Independent Appeal Panel is separate from the school - typically made up of lay members and members with relevant education experience. There are usually three people on the panel: a chair and at least two other members. A clerk manages the process and writes to you with the decision. You should normally get at least 10 school days’ notice of the hearing date.

Hearings can be held in person, remotely by video conference, or as a hybrid of the two - the admission authority decides the format, but whichever it chooses, you must be given the opportunity to make oral representations, not just submit something in writing.

Stage one: has the school established prejudice?

The school presents its case first - the number of applications received, the number of places available, its admission arrangements, and why admitting a further pupil would cause “prejudice” to the efficient provision of education or the efficient use of resources. The panel considers whether the admission arrangements were lawful and correctly applied, and whether admitting another pupil would actually cause that prejudice. If the panel finds that the admission authority has not established prejudice, and the admission arrangements were lawful and properly applied, the appeal will normally be upheld at this stage, without needing to weigh your individual case at all.

Stage two: your case

If the panel finds prejudice has been established, you present your case - why the school matters specifically for your child, any supporting circumstances, and your evidence. The panel then weighs your case against the degree of prejudice the school demonstrated in stage one. This is the stage where a clear, specific, evidence-led case (rather than general preference) makes the most difference. Note that infant class size appeals work differently - see our infant class size guide.

How to prepare

• Know your strongest two or three points, and lead with them rather than listing everything at once
• Have your evidence organised and ready to reference by name, not just described from memory
• Expect the panel to ask clarifying questions - answer directly and specifically rather than restating your written statement
• Stay factual and measured, even where the situation is genuinely upsetting - a calm, specific account tends to land better than an emotional one

The decision

The clerk will normally write to you shortly after the hearing to tell you the panel’s decision, although timescales vary between admission authorities and can take longer if the panel is hearing a large number of appeals together. Either the appeal is upheld (the school must offer a place) or refused (the original decision stands). No adviser, representative or service - including this one - can guarantee which outcome a panel will reach in your specific case.

Common mistakes parents make at the hearing

• Trying to cover every possible point rather than leading with the two or three strongest ones
• Reading the written statement aloud verbatim rather than answering the panel’s actual questions directly
• Bringing new evidence to the hearing that wasn’t submitted by the evidence deadline - see our deadlines and late evidence guide
• Preparing only for stage two before stage one has even been established, when preparation should genuinely cover both

Quick FAQ